1996-1997
Bob Dockemeyer-Missouri St.Louis
Gary Jewell-IUPU-Indianapolis
Keith Hopson-Kentucky State
Mark McCutchan-Oakland City
Jeff Nelson-Lindsey Wilson
Donnie Shemwell-Missouri-St.Louis
Mark Stampini-Wisconsin-Parkside
Chris Stevens-Lindsey Wilson
Tom Virgil-Western Illinois

1997-1998
Neftali Maldonado-Campbellsville
Dax O'Daniel-Kentucky
Javier Packeko-Clark College
Jason Pharr-Coker College
Sean Sullivan-Indiana
John Tackett-Coker College
Josh Thompson-IU Southeast

1998-1999
Jason Collins-IUPU-Ft. Wayne
Curtis Ellis-Tennessee Wesleyan
Sam Garau-South Carolins Aiken
Josh Hines-IU Southeast
Garrett Ivers-Aurora
Dan Luebbenhusen-Oakland City
Andy Mazzier-Murray State
Charlie Reed-Southern Illinois (Carbondale)
Dave Romain-Southern Indiana
Jeremy Ungethiem-IU Southeast
Tony Wolfe-Tennessee Wesleyan

1999-2000
Billy Hutslar-Indiana
Scott Kluesner-Austin Peay
Alexander Martinez-Central Christian
Randy Rice-Illinois State
Andy Rohleder-Evansville
Nathan Stone-Eastern Illinois
Adam Treat-IU Southeast
Mike Treat-IU Southeast
Mark Wahl-Dayton
Heath Wilke-Western Illinois

2000-2001
Justin Pouk-Texas A&M
Mike Garcia-Indiana
Matt Johnston-Western Kentucky
Chad Liter-Dayton
Chris Duncan-Eastern Illinois
Brian Lynn-Evansville
Trevor Kessling-Western Kentucky

2001-2002

Chad Kluesner-Central Arkansas
Brandon Scott-Eastern Kentucky
Terry Stone-Western Kentucky
Josh King-Old Dominion
Delmis Rosario-Spalding University
Pablo Bukonja-Oakland City University
Ezequiel Perez-Missouri Baptist
Eddie Rivera-Eastern Illinois
Nick Masur-Indiana State

2002-2003
Eric Brewer- Tennessee Tech University
Andy Hurt- University of Southern Indiana
Justin Mallory- Eastern Illinois University
Joe Peterson- Illinois State University
Joe Perez- Chicago State University
Josh King- Murray State University
Chad Grass- Armstrong Atlantic
Nic Lantz- William Woods College
Todd Dulaney-Ole Miss

2003-2004
Lance Trester - Northern Kentucky
Cole McConnell - Oakland City
Ken Pokryfke - Louisiana Lafayette
Dustin Brown - New Mexico State
Tony Nichting - Indiana/Purdue Fort Wayne
Ramon Downing - Missouri Baptist
Cory Gunter - Austin Peay
Adam Swain - Illinois State
Noerick Maldonado - Bethune Cookeman, FL
Rawell Rivera - Tennessee Weslyan

2004-2005
Josh Yates - University of Arkansas
Steve Smith - University of Kansas
Ken Pokryfke - University of Louisiana - Lafayette
Ben Norton - University of Evansville
Doug Eldridge - University of Illinois - Chicago
Cory Peabody - University of Purdue
Kelvin Davilla - Mississippi Valley State
Kyle Rapp - University of Cincinnatti
Asif Shah - University of Southeast Missouri State
Dallas Williams - Mississippi Valley State

2005-2006 
Andrew Bradley - Austin Peay - St. University
Levi Cheshire - Austin Peay - St. University
George Rosairmos - Univ. of Iowa
Joe Campbell - Univ. of Arkansas - Little Rock
Osvaldo Torres - Univ. of Arkansas - Little Rock
Alex Love - Delta State
Brent Davidson - Delta State
Dave Brumagin - Indiana State
Donnie Six - Indiana University

2006-2007
Brian Bernatowicz-Austin Peay-St. University
Wilfredo Cortes-Bethune-Cookman University
James Denton - Delta State University
Phil Hettlinger-Bowling Green
Josh Huebner-Univ. of Southern Indiana
Steve Karchefske-Bowling Green
Derek Melton-Univ. of Evansville
Jason Pabon-Lincoln Memorial University
Zack Starkey-Marist University
P.J. Thomas-Univ. of Southern Indiana
Bryan Willsey-Lambuth University

2007-2008
Aaron Barrett-Ole Miss
Chase Davenport-Norfolk State University
Jared Delong-Austin Peay University
Wade Dutton-Southern Illinois University-Carbondale
Josh Godfrey-University of Cincinnatti
Ben Ihde-Illinois State University
Jordan Jaehne-Llanas-University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
Brad Mangold-University of Southern Indiana
Kevin Mann-Indiana State University
Tyler Russell-University of Tennessee-Martin

2008-2009
Juan Alvarez-Lincoln Memorial University
Andrew Bryant-Alcorn State University
Keith Butler-University of Kentucky
Joe Devine-University of Kentucky
Casey Dishman-Michigan State University
Blake Drake-University of Arkansas
Yovan Gonzalez- Tennessee Wesleyan University
Nathan Humphrey-Oakland City University
Matt Klees-Indiana University SE
Causton Merchant-Alcorn State University
Julio Morales-Bethune Cookman University
Daniel Nichols-Louisiana-Lafayette 
Ryan Santos-Tennessee Wesleyan University
Chris Stallion-Oakland City University
JT Stenftenagel-Indiana State University

2009-2010
Michael Mosby - Western Kentucky University
Tyler Oliver - University of Kentucky
Tyler Dunaway - University of Kentucky
Jacob Rhodes - Murray State University
Danny Gifford - Bradley University
Tory Doerr - Bradley University
Ryan Rogers - Morehead State University
Dean Stuckey - Purdue University
Daniel Bollenbacher - Lincoln Memorial University
Eric Hillenbrand - Lincoln Memorial University
Austin Park - University of Northwest Ohio
Dominic Spadafora - Taylor University

2010-2011
Steve Hodgins - Western Kentucky University
Noah Zipko - Murray State University
Alex Gordon - Murray State University
Keith Koser - Eastern Illinois University
Shane Crain - University of Louisville
BJ Willis - Southern Indiana University
Edmanuel Rivera - Lee University
Christian Cardenas - University of Wisconsin-Parkside
Chris Glynn - University of Wisconsin-Parkside
Branden Winschief - Oakland City University
Jacob Goldenberg - Northern Illinois University

2011-2012
Conor Fisk - Southern Mississippi University
Mark Fowler - Wright State University
AJ Dokey - Southern Indiana University
Nick Heinz - Southern Indiana University 
Gabriel Roa - Lee University 
Cody Leichman – Central Michigan University
Ryan Riga – Ohio State University
Korey Hall – Grambling University
Brandon Ollet – Alcorn State University
Reid Van Bussum – Northwestern State University

2012-2013
Brandon Allen - Western Kentucky University
Conor Dishman - Texas Southern University
Spencer Drake - University of Cincinnati
Matt Ellenbest - Morehead State University
Edgar Figueroa - Purdue University
Matt Geislinger - Minnesota State University
Cole Gleason - University of South Alabama
Garrett Gordon - University of Arkansas
Danny Heim - Maryville University
James Jewell - Purdue University
Dennis Olszewski - Wayne State University
Ryan Quintero - Jacksonville University
Kyle Rupe - Indiana University Southeast
Spencer Sapp - University of Ohio
Tyler Shewmaker - Kentucky Wesleyan College
Jeff Smith - Missouri Baptist University
Nate Snellgrove - University of Cincinnati
Clay Wallace - University of Cincinnati

2013-2014
Ty Amann - Northern Kentucky University
Manuel DeJesus - Ohio University
Phillip Diehl - Louisiana Tech University
Dane Giesler - Indiana State University
Rey Perez - Florida International University
Matthew Pletzke - Northern Kentucky University
Matthew Schultz - University of Illinois

2014-2015
Angel Alicea - Alabama State University
Clay Chandler - Southeast Missouri State University
Wesley Drain - Grambling State University
Collin Edwards - University of Tennessee at Martin
Todd Goldberg - University of Tennnessee at Martin
Travis Herrin - Indiana University
Zach Lewis - Wichita State University
Nick McCoy - University of Central Florida 
Jacob Murray - University of Central Arkansas
Carlos Ocasio - Alabama State University 
Carlos Pena - Barry University 
Anthony Penas - Winthrop University
Claudio Rubiera - University of Southern Mississippi
Tanner Schumacher - Purdue University
Ben Spitznagel - University of North Carolina Greensboro
Kevin Suarez - Florida International University
Josh Van Beek - Indiana-Purdue University Fort Wayne 

2015-2016

Kyle Griffin- University of Houston
Trey Davidon- University of Southern Miss
Brandon Kelley- University of Indiana
Butch Baird- Ohio University
Ryan Campbell- University of Illinois Chicago
Juan Martinez- St. Thomas University

Anthony Justiniano- St. Thomas University 
Zach Shannon- Delta St. University

2016-2017

Liam Jenkins – University of Louisville
Aaron McGeorge – University Kentucky
Malcolm Grady – Western Kentucky University
Trey Beckman – University of Illinois-Chicago
Diego Pichardo – Bethany College
Austen Bullington – University of Tennessee-Martin
Jefferey O'Doherty -- University of Tennesse--Martin
Jared Proctor – University of South Alabama
Jarod Watkins – Indiana St. University 
Romero Harris – Indiana St. University
Alex Lee – Eastern Illinois University
Kendall King – Georgetown 
Collin Luty – Northern Kentucky University
Cameron Shryock – Austin Peay St. University
Braden Giroux -- Purdue University
Bailey Montgomery -- Western Illinois University 

2017-2018

Korren Thompson -- University of Cincinatti
Joe Vranesic -- Western Carolina University 
Kobe Stephens -- Southern Indiana University
Hunter Wolfe --  University of Dayton
Matt Burch -- Old Dominion University 
Collin Lollar -- Western Kentucky University
Ryan Layne -- Morehead State University
Matt Jewell -- Northern Kentucky University
J Paul Fullerton -- University of Alabama-Birmingham (UAB)
Austin Moralis -- Indiana St. University
Dylan Burris -- Southern Illinois University (Edwardsville)
Brian Chandler -- Southern Illinois University (Edwardsville) 
Dalton Shoemake -- Western Kentucky University 

2018-2019